Mathematics Year 5 workbook - can you detect the errors?

In my previous post Buying Workbooks For Your Kids, I've mentioned about a publisher who published poor quality Mathematics workbook.

I was at a bookshop in Petaling Jaya few weeks ago. As I was browsing through some new workbooks, I came across a new series of books published under an unfamiliar name.

Since we are in our 5th year of using Maths and Science in English, I chose their Mathematics Year 5 workbook under the series Infomik UPSR (is there such word as Infomik?). I was completely shocked! I knew the new Year 5 syllabus well because I've just completed writing two new Maths workbooks.

Click on these pictures (including the front cover) and see if you can spot the errors. These are just three pages (yes, there are more mistakes and I'm not talking about typo errors alone). I don't mind if these are just some minor typo errors but incorrect sentences with grammatical errors that pupils might not be able to understand is simply unacceptable.

The most surprising thing is, according to the bookshop owner, this publisher's books got into school list. I hope it's not their Maths workbooks.

At the beginning, I was reluctant to comment about this book, well, since I have to fork out about RM9 (very pricey!) to get hold of this book. But for the sake of the pupils, I couldn't tutup sebelah mata (close one eye).

5 drop shot(s):

1. fishtail said,

   I am equally shocked. But wait .. considering this is Bolehland of Corruption and Cover Ups, I shouldn't be shocked after all. Pity the students.

   on 3:22 PM  

   
   
2. narrowband said,

   Horrors!!
   
   Talk about learning Maths and Science in English!

   on 4:41 PM  

   
   
3. Dancing Queen said,

   I'm simply appalled by the grammatical and typo errors! I've got a kid in Y5 next year. When she told me the way her English teacher pronounced certain words, I was just flabbergasted! Good thing, she knows the difference. She's just keeping quiet lest the teacher thinks she's a smart alec! Pity those who don't know.

   on 6:37 PM  

   
   
4. zewt said,

   so not only the teachers are getting screwed up...

   on 1:17 AM  

   
   
5. hcfoo said,

   zewt: what to do...

   on 6:15 PM  

   
   

Post a Comment